The Great Discounting Debate: Empower Sales or Protect Value?
Insights from Our Latest Pricing Gym Session
The discussion was intense. Pricing leaders from manufacturing, SaaS, infrastructure, and consulting gathered for our latest Pricing Gym session to tackle a deceptively simple—but deeply complex—question:
Should sales teams have the flexibility to discount?
What followed was one of our most heated and insightful debates yet—a showdown between market responsiveness and value discipline that exposed core fault lines in how B2B organizations approach pricing strategy.
Two Camps, One Critical Question
The debate quickly split into two distinct philosophies:
🔒 Strict Adherence Camp
“Set your prices and stick to them. Every discount is a crack in your value proposition.”
This group argued that discounting erodes perceived value, trains customers to expect price drops, and undermines pricing integrity. Their rallying cry: anchor pricing to value, not win rates.
🔓 Guided Flexibility Camp
“Sales teams are your market sensors. Give them tools—not guesswork.”
This group supported pricing agility, but with smart guardrails. They championed structured discount frameworks aligned with margin tiers, arguing that even 70%+ discounts can make sense in high-margin models when applied strategically.
The Training Gap That Costs Millions
One of the session’s most striking moments came from comparing sales vs. procurement training.
While procurement teams receive quarterly updates on negotiation tactics, many sales teams get annual refreshers—if that. This creates a dangerous asymmetry. When sales is outgunned, unguarded discounting becomes a crutch instead of a strategy.
6 Game-Changing Insights
Context is King
Your discounting strategy must match your margin structure, complexity, and scale. One-size doesn’t fit all.Guardrails Beat Gut Feel
Smart discount bands by customer segment, margin, and approval level prevent chaos—without handcuffing sales.Training Gaps Kill Margins
Empower sales with ongoing pricing education and involve pricing experts in complex deals.Discounts Aren’t the Only Lever
Explore volume scales, rebates, and geo-specific pricing to preserve value under pressure.Legal & Compliance Must Be Involved
Predatory pricing and compliance risks can’t be ignored—legal, finance, and pricing need to collaborate.Peer Benchmarking Builds Discipline
When rigid policies aren’t an option, peer transparency and deal reviews promote pricing accountability.
Discounting Sends a Message
Discounting isn’t just a tactic—it’s a cultural signal. Every approved discount tells your team, your market, and your customers how you define your value.
The takeaway? It’s not about banning discounting. It’s about governing it with discipline. Top-performing teams don’t eliminate flexibility—they channel it through intelligent structures that align with profitability and strategy.
Your Next Move
As you review your pricing practices, ask:
Are sales teams trained to defend value, or defaulting to price cuts?
Do your discount rules support your margin goals?
Are you tracking discounting trends to catch breakdowns?
What message are you sending about your offer’s worth?
You’re either reinforcing your value or training buyers to expect a markdown.
*
Want to level up your pricing game?
Ready to sharpen your pricing thinking? Join our weekly Pricing Gym sessions where we tackle real-world pricing challenges with no fluff—just practical insights from pricing leaders across industries.
